Jones machine/Maxrack vs. Smith machine: history, definitions and efficacy overview

Issue: Vol. 5 No 3

Published by Journal of Fitness Research, 08/12/2016. Volume 5.3

Tags: Smith Machine , Jones Machine , MaxRack , Strength , Power , Testing , Free Weight , Squat , Bench Press.

Download PDF Version »

  1. Neil Wolkodoff (Corresponding Author)
    Colorado Center for Health & Sport Science
  2. Felipe Eichenberger
    Denver Nuggets Basketball Team, NBA

Abstract

Introduction: The Smith Machine has been a popular alternative to free bar exercises because of perceivedsafety advantages. With the advent of the Jones Machine/MaxRack, it is still a viable alternative to freeweight training? Does the Jones Machine/MaxRack have a better combination of free weight resultscombined with enhanced safety?

History: The Smith Machine, with a fixed vertical motion, was pioneered in the late 1930s, and was adoptedin response to increased interest in resistance training, while the Jones Machine/MaxRack were invented incombination to the path options of a free bar combined with safety consideration.

Bar Path Comparison: The bench press, deadlift and power clean are exercises that do not have acompletely linear path. The squat, in performance, is ideally linear, yet not in learning the exercise. The SmithMachine does not allow the bar path used in major free weight exercises.

Strength Testing: Because of inherent friction and bar path limitations, the use of a Smith Machine in testingfor free weight-based strength gains is not valid.

Conclusions: The Smith Machine does not match the free bar path of the major exercises, while the JonesMachine/MaxRack allow exercise specific and individual bar path variations and matching.

Download PDF Version »


Also In This Issue

« Back to Articles


Article Title

Jones machine/Maxrack vs. Smith machine: history, definitions and efficacy overview

Journal Title

Journal of Fitness Research Volume 5.3

Online Publication Date

08/12/2016

Author Names

Neil Wolkodoff (Corresponding Author)
Felipe Eichenberger

1. Abelbeck, K.G. (2002). Biomechanical model and evaluation of a linear motion squat type exercise.Journal of Strength & Conditioning Research, 16(4):516-24.

2. Algra, B. (1982). An In-Depth Analysis of the Bench Press. National Strength & Conditioning Association Journal, 4(5):6-11, 70-72.

3. Atle Hole Saeterbakken, A.T., van den Tillaar, R.,Fimland, M. (2011). A comparison of muscle activity and 1-RM strength of three chest press exercises with different stability requirements.Journal of Sports Sciences, 29(5):533-8.

4. Buckley, J. (1997). Closed kinetic chain – an openor shut case? Frontline: 8-9.

5. Buddhadev, H.H., Vingren, J.L, Duplanty, A.A.,and Hill, D.W. (2012). Mechanisms underlying the reduced performance measures from using equipment with a counterbalance weight system.Journal of Strength & Conditioning Research, 26(3):641–647, 2012

6. Chiu, L.Z.F., Heiler, J., and Sorenson, S.C. (2009).Sitting back in the squat. Journal of Strength &Conditioning Research, 31: 25–27.

7. Clark D.R., Lambert, M.I., Hunter A.M. (2012).Muscle activation in the loaded free barbell squat:a brief review. Journal of Strength & Conditioning Research, 26(4):1169-78.

8. Cotterman, M.L., Darby, L.A., Skelly, W.A. (2005).Comparison of muscle force production using the Smith machine and free weights for bench press and squat exercises. Journal of Strength & Conditioning Research, 19(1), 169-76.

9. Cormie, P., McCaulley, G.O., Triplett, T,N., and McBride, J.M. (2007). Optimal loading for maximal power output during lower-body resistance exercises. Medicine & Science, in Sports & Exercise,39: 340–349, 2007.

10. Cronin, J., Sleivert, G. (2005). Challenges in understanding the inï¬ï¿½uence of maximal power training on improving athletic performance. Sports Medicine, 35: 213–234.

11. Decker M, Krong J, Peterson D, Anstett T, Torry M, Giphart E, Duffey MJ, Challis JH. (2007).Fatigue Effects on bar kinematics during the bench press. Journal of Strength & Conditioning Research. 21(2):556-560.

12. Derwin, B.P. (1990). The snatch: technical description and periodization program. National Strength & Conditioning Association Journal. 12(2):6-14, 80-91.

13. Duffey, M.J., Challis, J.H. (2007). Fatigue effects on bar kinematics during the bench press. Journal of Strength & Conditioning Research, 21(2):556-560.

14. Duffey, M.J., and Challis, J.H. (2011). Vertical and lateral forces applied to the bar during the bench press in novice lifters. Journal of Strength &Conditioning Research, 25(9):2442-2447.

15. Escamilla, R.F., Fleisig, G.S., Zheng, N., Lander,J.E., Barrentine, S.W., Andrews, J.R., Bergemann,B.W., Moorman, C.T, 3rd. (1998). Biomechanics of the knee during closed kinetic chain and open kinetic chain exercises. Medicine & Science in Sports& Exercise, 30(4), 556-69.

16. Escamilla, R.F., Fleisig, G.S., Lowry, T.M.,Barrentine, S.W., Andrews, J.R. (2001). A three dimensional biomechanical analysis of the squat during varying stance widths. Medicine & Science inSports & Exercise, 33: 984–998.

17. Escamilla, R.F., Fleisig, G.S., Zheng, N., Lander,J.E., Barrentine, S.W., Andrews, J.R., Bergemann,B.W., Moorman, C.T. (2001), Effects of technique variations on knee biomechanics during the squat and leg press. Medicine & Science in Sports &Exercise, 33: 1552–1566.

18. Fry, A.C., Smith, C., Schilling, B.K. (2003). Effect of knee position on hip and knee torques during the barbell squat. Journal of Strength & Conditioning Research, 17:629–633.

19. Gaines, C., Butler, G. 1974. Pumping Iron: The Art and Sport of Bodybuilding. New York: Simon and Schuster.

20. Garhammer, J. (1984). Kinesiological Evaluation of the Power Clean. National Strength &Conditioning Association Journal, 6(3):40, 61-63.

21. Gotschalk, L. Analysis of the deadlift.(1985).National Strength & Conditioning Association Journal,6(6):4-5, 74-76, 78.

22. Gutierrez, A., Bahamonde, R.E. (2009). Kinematic analysis of the traditional back squat and smith machine squat exercises. In ISBS-Conference Proceedings Archive, (Volume 1, No. 1).

23. Hales ME, Johnson BF, and Johnson JT. (2009).Kinematic analysis of the power lifting style squat and the conventional deadlift during competition:Is there a cross-over effect between lifts? Journal of Strength & Conditioning Research, 23:2574–2580.

24. Hopkins, J.T., Ingersoll, C.D., Sandrey, M.A.,Bleggi, S,D. (1998). An EMG comparison of four closed chain exercise with limited knee range of motion. Journal of Athletic Training, 33(2) Suppl.S-75.

25. Ireland, M.L. (2002). The female ACL: Why is it more prone to injury? Orthopedic Clinics of North America, 33: 637–651.

26. Javorek, I. (1986). Teaching of technique in the snatch and the clean and jerk. National Strength &Conditioning Association Journal, 8(3):45-51.27. Kennedy, J.F. 1960. The soft American. Sports Illustrated, (December 26).

28. Kennedy, J.F. 1962. The vigor we need. Sports Illustrated, (July 16).29. Kolber, M.J., Beekhuizen, K.S., Cheng, M-S,S.,Hellman, M.A. (2010). Shoulder injuries attributed to resistance training: a brief review. Journal of Strength & Conditioning Research, 24(6):1696-1704.

30. Luebbers, P.E., Fry, A.C. (2016). The Kansas Squat Test Modality Comparison: Free-Weights vs. Smith Machine. Journal of Strength & Conditioning Research,Mar 3. [Epub ahead of print]

31. McBride, J.M., Skinner, J.W., Schafer, P,C,, Haines,T.L., Kirby, T,J. (2010). Comparison of kinetic variables and muscle activity during a squat vs. abox squat. Journal of Strength & Conditioning Research, 24(12):3195–3199.

32. McCaw, S.T., Melrose, R. (1999). Stance width andbar load effects on leg muscle activity during the parallel squat. Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise, 31:428–436.

33. McCaw, S.T., Friday, J,J. (1994) A comparison of muscle activity between a free weight and machine bench press. Journal of Strength & Conditioning Research,8:259-64, 82.

34. McLaughlin, T,M. (1984). Bench press techniques of elite heavyweight power lifters. National Strength& Conditioning Association Journal, 6(4):44, 62-65.

35. McLaughlin, T.M., Dillman, C.J., Lardner, T.J.(1977). A kinematic model of performance in the parallel squat by champion power lifters. Medicine &Science in Sports & Exercise, 9: 28–133.

36. McLaughlin, T.M., Lardner, T.J., Dillman, CJ.(1978). Kinetics of the parallel squat. Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport, 49(2):175-89.37. Nationwide Children’s Hospital. (2010). Weight training-related injuries increasing. Science Daily.

38. O’Shea, P. (1985). The Parallel squat. National Strength & Conditioning Association Journal, 7(1): 4-6,78.

39. Paoli, A., Marcolin, G., Petrone, N. (2009). Theeffect of stance width on the electromyographical activity of eight superï¬ï¿½cial thigh muscles during back squat with different loads. Journal of Strength& Conditioning Research, 23:246–250.

40. Pereira, G.R., Leporace, G., Chagas, D.V., Furtado,L.F.L., Praxedes, J, Batista, L.A. (2010). Inï¬ï¿½uenceof hip external rotation on hip adductor and rectus femoris myoelectric activity during a dynamic parallel squat. Journal of Strength &Conditioning Research, 24:2749–2754.

41. Rivera, J.U. (1994). Open versus closed kinetic chain rehabilitation of the lower extremity: a functional and biomechanical analysis. Journal of Sport Rehabilitation, 3:154-167.

42. Robertson, D.G., Wilson, J.M., St. Pierre, T,A.(2008). Lower extremity muscle functions during full squats. Journal of Applied Biomechanics, 24(4):333-9.

43. Sale, D.G. (1988). Neural adaptations to resistance training. Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise,20:135-45.

44. Schick, E.E., Coburn, J.W., Brown, L.E., Judelson,D.A., Khamoui, A.V., Tran, T.T., and Uribe, B.P.(2010). A comparison of muscle activation between a Smith machine and free weight bench press. Journal of Strength & Conditioning Research,24(3): 779-784.

45. Schoenfeld, B.J. (2010). Squatting kinematics and kinetics and their application to exercise performance. Journal of Strength & Conditioning Research, 24: 3497–3506.

46. Schwanbeck, S., Chilibeck, P,D., Binsted, G. (2009).A comparison of free weight squat to Smith machine squat using electromyography. Journal of Strength & Conditioning Research, 23(9):2588–2591.

47. Scott, B.R., Dascombe, B.J., Delaney, J,A,,Elsworthy, N., Lockie, R.G., Sculley, D.V., Slattery,K.M. (2014). The validity and reliability of a customized rigid supportive harness during Smith machine back squat exercise. Journal of Strength &Conditioning Research, 28(3):636–642, 2014.

48. Shelburne, K., Philippon, M. (2009). Deep hip muscle activation during a squat exercise. In:Proceedings of the American Society of Biomechanics. PA.

49. Silver, T, Fortenbaugh, D., Williams, R. (2009).Effects of the Bench Shirt on Sagittal Bar Path.Journal of Strength & Conditioning Research, 23(4)1125-1128.

50. Spennewyn, K.C. (2008) Strength outcomes in fixed versus free-form resistance equipment.Journal of Strength & Conditioning Research, 22(1):75-81.

51. Steindler A. (1955). Kinesiology of the human body. Springfield, IL: Charles C. Thomas.

52. Van den Tillaar, R., Sæterbakken, A. (2012). The sticking region in three chest-press exercises with increasing degrees of freedom. Journal of Strength& Conditioning Research, 26(11):2962–2969.

53. Vingren, J.L., Buddhadev, H.H., Hill, D.W. (2011).Smith machine counterbalance system affects measures of maximal bench press throw performance. Journal of Strength & Conditioning Research, 25(7):1951-1956, 2011.

54. Welch, P. D. (1996). History of American Physical Education and Sport (2nd ed.). Springfield, IL:Charles C. Thomas.

55. Wretenberg, P., Feng, Y., Arborelius, U.P. (1996).High- and low-bar squatting techniques during weight-training. Medicine & Science in Sports &Exercise, 28:218–224.

56. Wu, H., Lee, S., Kao, J., Wang, S. Three dimensional kinetic analysis of lower limbs in barbell squat. In: Proceedings of 37th Annual Northeast Bioengineering Conference. Rochester,NY: 2011

No citations available


Comments

Blog comments powered by Disqus